top of page
  • Writer's pictureAlpesh Patel

Pension Woes Magnified: A Closer Look at the Royal London Henderson China Fund's Downturn

In the ever-evolving landscape of investment opportunities, the Royal London Henderson China Opportunities Fund has recently come under scrutiny.

With China being the world's second-largest economy, expectations for this fund have been high, given the potential for growth and profitability in such a dynamic market. However, a closer examination of the fund's performance over the last few years reveals a somewhat disconcerting picture for investors, particularly those relying on their pensions.

A Closer Look at the Fund's Performance

Despite the allure of investing in the burgeoning Chinese market, the fund's performance has been less than stellar. With a rating of three crowns out of five, it might initially seem like a decent investment. However, this rating system, which often generously awards performance, suggests that the fund's achievements are not as commendable as one might hope.

Over the last five years, a period during which one would expect a fund focused on China to thrive, the results have been disappointing. The fund has found itself in the bottom 25% of its category, indicating a consistent underperformance relative to its peers. This is particularly concerning given the significant growth potential in the Chinese market.

For investors who have been with the fund for five years, the impact is stark, with a quarter of their pension value eroded. Those who joined three years ago have faced even more severe losses, with half a year's pension value disappearing. This is in stark contrast to the broader market performance, with the S&P 500 and NASDAQ showing substantial gains of 25% and 55%, respectively, over the past year.

Management and Strategy

The fund is managed by M. Ling, who joined Henderson in 2015. Despite her tenure, the fund's recent performance raises questions about the investment strategy and decision-making process. With a fund size of 7 million, the impact of these losses fortunately affects a relatively small group of investors. However, this is little consolation to those whose financial futures are tied to the fund's success.

The focus on global emerging market equities, including significant investments in companies like Tencent and Alibaba, has not yielded the expected returns. This suggests a potential misalignment between the fund's strategy and the realities of the market or possibly a misjudgment in the execution of this strategy.

Reflections and Recommendations

The underwhelming performance of the Royal London Henderson China Opportunities Fund serves as a cautionary tale for investors. It highlights the importance of thorough due diligence and the need for fund managers to adapt to changing market conditions. While the allure of high-growth markets like China is undeniable, this case underscores the risks involved and the potential for significant losses.

For the management team at Henderson, this period should be a time for reflection and potentially a reassessment of their investment strategies. While it's easy to suggest drastic measures such as changing management or overhauling investment approaches, the solution may lie in a more nuanced understanding of the Chinese market and a strategic adjustment to navigate its complexities more effectively.

Investing in emerging markets remains a tempting proposition for those seeking to diversify their portfolios and tap into growth opportunities. However, as the Royal London Henderson China Opportunities Fund illustrates, such investments come with their own set of challenges and risks. For investors, the key lies in balancing the potential for high returns with the reality of market volatility and the importance of informed, strategic decision-making.

Alpesh Patel OBE


bottom of page