top of page
  • Writer's pictureAlpesh Patel

10 Reasons UK Fund Managers Are Underperforming and Why You Need to Take Control of Your Pension

Updated: Jul 11

The financial landscape is changing, and recent insights highlight a significant issue: UK fund managers are underperforming. Here are ten key reasons behind this trend and why it's crucial to take charge of your pension investments.

  1. Persistent Underperformance: According to a recent SPIVA report, 95% of actively managed UK small-cap equity funds underperformed the S&P United Kingdom SmallCap index in the first six months of 2023, the highest ever underperformance rate for this category​ (The Evidence-Based Investor)​.

  2. High Management Fees: High fees continue to erode returns for investors. Active fund managers often charge higher fees than passive funds, but many fail to deliver better performance. This disparity is a major contributor to the underperformance of active funds​ (FT Adviser)​. UK pension plans overpay £1.5bn in fees to fund managers​ (The Evidence-Based Investor)​.

  3. Economic and Geopolitical Uncertainty: The pandemic, Brexit, and geopolitical tensions, such as the Russia-Ukraine conflict, have created volatile market conditions. These uncertainties have posed significant challenges for fund managers, impacting their ability to generate consistent returns​ (moneyweekuk)​.

  4. Market Volatility and Sector Concentration: The performance of a few large technology stocks has driven market gains, leaving many funds that lack exposure to these "magnificent seven" stocks struggling. This sector concentration has made it difficult for diversified funds to keep up​ (moneyweekuk)​​ (The Evidence-Based Investor)​.

  5. Stringent Regulations: Regulatory burdens can hinder fund managers' ability to innovate and adapt quickly. Navigating these complex regulatory landscapes can limit the strategies available to fund managers, affecting their performance​ (FT Adviser)​.

  6. Lack of Innovation: UK fund managers have been criticised for their conservative investment approaches and reluctance to adopt innovative strategies and technologies. This stagnation prevents them from capitalising on new growth opportunities​ (FT Adviser)​.

  7. High Number of Dog Funds: Bestinvest’s latest Spot the Dog report revealed that 151 equity investment funds, holding £95.26 billion of investors’ wealth, have consistently underperformed their benchmarks over the past three years. This is a 170% increase from mid-2023​ (moneyweekuk)​.

  8. Global Competition: UK fund managers face stiff competition from their global counterparts, who often have more resources and a broader reach. This global competition puts additional pressure on UK fund managers to perform better​ (Interactive Investor)​.

  9. Talent Drain: The UK financial sector has experienced a talent drain, with top professionals moving to markets offering better opportunities. This loss of talent impacts the quality of fund management and contributes to underperformance​ (Interactive Investor)​.

  10. Investor Disillusionment: Continuous underperformance has led to a loss of confidence among investors. Many are pulling out their investments, further destabilising funds and reducing their ability to recover and grow​ (Interactive Investor)​.

Why You Need to Take Control of Your Pension

Given these challenges, it’s more important than ever to take control of your pension investments. Relying solely on traditional UK fund managers could jeopardise your financial future. Instead, consider diversifying your portfolio, exploring low-cost index funds, and staying informed about where and how your money is being managed.

For more insights and strategies on securing your financial future, visit Let’s take control of our financial destiny together!

Alpesh Patel OBE


bottom of page