top of page
  • Writer's pictureAlpesh Patel

Unveiling the Truth Behind Pension Underperformance: A Case Study of Zurich Managed Equity Focus

When it comes to securing our financial future, the performance of our pension funds is paramount. Many of us place our trust in seemingly reputable investment options, like the Zurich Managed Equity Focus, expecting them to deliver substantial returns over time. However, a closer examination reveals a startling reality that challenges the efficacy of such managed funds.

The Disappointing Reality

On paper, the Zurich Managed Equity Focus fund sounds promising. It's managed by a reputable firm, focuses on equities, and therefore, should theoretically yield impressive returns. Yet, the actual performance tells a different story.

Over a three-year period, the fund has returned a mere 7% - a figure that barely competes with the interest rates offered by some banks. Extending the analysis to a five-year period only slightly improves the picture, with a 38% return. While this might not seem dismal at first glance, the context changes dramatically when these figures are compared to broader market performances.

A Stark Comparison

Over the same five-year span, the NASDAQ surged by approximately 100%, and the S&P 500 saw an increase of over 82%. Even over three years, both indices significantly outperformed the Zurich fund, with gains ranging between 26 to 30%. This stark contrast raises a critical question: why is there such a vast discrepancy between the performance of this managed fund and the broader market?

The Underlying Issue

Digging deeper, we find that the fund's strategy involves investing in other funds managed by the fund manager's colleagues. This approach not only layers fees upon fees but also dilutes the potential for high returns. Essentially, investors are paying multiple layers of management fees for the privilege of underperformance.

The Real Winners

While investors may not be seeing the returns they hoped for, the fund managers and their network certainly benefit from this arrangement. Through fees collected on the invested capital, regardless of performance, they ensure their financial well-being, often at the expense of the average investor's retirement dreams.

A Call to Action

This situation underscores a broader issue within the investment management industry, where the interests of fund managers can misalign with those of their clients. It's a reminder for investors to scrutinise where their money is going and how it's being managed. For those invested in underperforming funds like the Zurich Managed Equity Focus, it might be time to reconsider their investment strategy.

Leveraging Knowledge for Better Investment Decisions

Fortunately, there are resources available for investors looking to take control of their financial future. With a wealth of information at our fingertips, including books and financial columns dedicated to investment strategies and fund management critique, individuals can educate themselves on making more informed decisions.

In the end, the goal is not just to invest but to invest wisely. By understanding the mechanisms behind fund performance and the potential conflicts of interest within the fund management industry, investors can better navigate their way towards a more secure financial future.

Alpesh Patel OBE


bottom of page